From simple to elaborate, Sift Cakes by Wild Horse Catering are a delicious addition to your special day! Let us help you create a cake that fits your personality, style and budget — beautifully.  If you do not see a flavor you are looking for, please ask and we will do our best to accommodate.

Cake Flavors

  • Vanilla
  • Chocolate
  • Assorted fruit
  • Assorted nuts
  • Carrot-ginger
  • Red Velvet

Cake Fillings

  • Fruit — assorted
  • Ganache – chocolate or chocolate nut*
  • Cream Cheese
  • Lemon curd
  • Flavored buttercream – assorted flavors (Chocolate, salted caramel, almond, white chocolate mocha and more)
  • Marshmallow and crushed graham crackers
  • Vanilla bean pastry cream


  • Italian meringue buttercream – can be flavored
  • Classic American buttercream – can be flavored
  • Chocolate
  • Cream cheese
  • Fondant*

(Any icing may also be used as a filling)


  • Winter Park – Chocolate — Our chocolate cake, filled with chocolate ganache, frosted with chocolate buttercream
  • Mary Jane – Vanilla — Our vanilla cake, filled with vanilla bean pastry cream, frosted with vanilla buttercream
  • Goofy – Chocolate/Vanilla — Chocolate cake, chocolate ganache, vanilla buttercream
  • Bugs Bunny – Carrot — Carrot ginger cake, orange ginger filling, cream cheese frosting
  • Campfire – Smores — Your choice chocolate or vanilla cake, chocolate ganache, crushed graham crackers, and marshmallow filling, vanilla buttercream, topped with crushed graham crackers, a marshmallow, and chocolate drizzle
  • Wake Me Up Buttercup – Chocolate Espresso — Chocolate espresso cake, salted caramel filling, white chocolate mocha buttercream, topped with a chocolate covered espresso bean and chocolate drizzle
  • Summer Lovin – Raspberry Lemonade — Raspberry cake, lemon curd filling, lavender infused buttercream, topped with a fresh raspberry and candied lemon peel
  • Winter Solstice – Hot Chocolate — Chocolate cake, creamy chocolate fudge filling, vanilla buttercream, topped with chocolate drizzle and mini marshmallows *make it peppermint
  • Ooey Gooey – sticky bun — Cinnamon swirl cake, filled with salted caramel and pecans, topped with vanilla buttercream, a salted caramel drizzle, and more pecans
  • Late Night Snack – Chocolate pretzels — Chocolate cake with a salted caramel filling, chocolate buttercream, and topped with pretzel pieces and more salted caramel
  • Pirates’ Life – Cookies and Cream — A black and white cake made with vanilla cake and crushed cookies, filled with cookies and cream, topped with vanilla buttercream and crushed cookies
  • 26.2 – marathon snickers cupcake — Chocolate cupcake, filled with salted caramel and peanuts, topped with salted caramel buttercream, salted caramel and chocolate drizzle, and more peanuts
  • Home Sweet Home – Apple Pie — Vanilla spice cake, apple cinnamon filling, brown sugar buttercream
  • Braums Sundae – Hot Fudge Sundae — Vanilla cake, filled with chocolate ganache, topped with vanilla buttercream, chocolate drizzle, and a cherry.
  • As You Wish – red velvet — Nothing says true love like our red velvet cake filled with chocolate ganache, topped with a cream cheese frosting, chocolate drizzle, and a delicate chocolate pieceCorona Pass – Rocky road — This chocolate cake, filled with marshmallow cream, is topped with a chocolate buttercream, chocolate drizzle, mini marshmallows, and roasted nuts

(Minimum order of six per flavor)


  • Sheet cake, only available to supplement larger orders. $3-4 per person
  • Simply beautiful, small tiered cake with textured buttercream. $4-5  per person
  • Cupcakes.  $4-5 per person
  • Mid-level cake, with minimal decoration, buttercream icing. $5-6 per person
  • Fondant covered cake. $6-$7 per person
  • Intricate designs with buttercream or fondant. $7-10 depending on level of difficulty

*(Denotes an extra charge)